Why The National League Will Win The All-Star Game In 2009 / HR Derby Predictions

The All-Star Game is one of the most anticipated events for me every year. Unfortunately, I am a National League supporter and they have no faired to well in my lifetime. Since I was born, there have been 17 all-star games. Of those 17 games, the National League has a record of 2-14-1. That is not good. Some say it’s because the American League has more talent than the National League, well I just call it luck. Here are 5 reasons why the National League will win their first all-star game since 1996 this year:

  1. Pitching. The National League roster features 3 of the top 5 arms in baseball, which is better than 2 of the top 5. Tim Lincecum, Johan Santana, and Dan Haren will all make appearances  Tuesday. Although the back end of the bullpen is probably weaker than the American League, I still think they have good enough arms to get it done (Trevor Hoffman, Fransisco Rodriguez, Heath Bell, Francisco Cordero). The American Leagues big arms come with a lot of youth and inexperience. Zack Greinke, Justin Verlander, Edwin Jackson, and Felix Hernandez have 1 all-star appearance between them (Verlander in ’07). 
  2. The ballpark. The National League has always seemed to fair better in NL Central ballparks. In 2007 the NL lost in the 9th inning in PNC Park. In 2002 the National League tied in Miller Park. In 1994 the National League won the game in Three Rivers Stadium. The only time they haven’t been competitive was in 2004 when the AL won 9-4 in Minutemaid Park. 
  3. The current state of the game. Over the last few years, Major League Baseball has shifted towards a more defensive, youthful, fast core of players. It seems the teams that are successful have a lot of young, 5-tool talent. The National League squad has a lot more of these types of players than the American League. Hanley Ramirez, Ryan Braun, Orlando Hudson, Ryan Zimmerman, Justin Upton, and Shane Victorino all fit this mold. The American League has a couple of these guys as well (Carl Crawford, Adam Jones) but they don’t nearly meet what the NL has. The game has been changing slowly and we are really seeing it in full force this season, and the NL squad best accompanies those changes. 
  4. Freddy Sanchez & Zach Duke. No, I am not saying that Sanchez and Duke are going to greatly attribute to the victory. What I am saying is that the last time the NL won an all-star game (1996) the Pirates had 2 all-star representatives. Jason Kendall and Mike Williams both made the team. This is one of the only times in my lifetime that the Pirates have had 2 all-star representatives and they made the most of it in 1996. 
  5. Because I Said So. If I didn’t have one of those feelings about this game, I wouldn’t have made this post. Something is just telling me that the NL is going to get the job done this year. This is the 13th All-Star game since the National League’s last victory, and 13 is the lucky number. Yes, that just happened. 
So there you have it, the 5 reasons that the National League will defeat the American League Tuesday night and earn World Series Home Advantage for the Pittsburgh Pirates in late October. I’ll have more on the game and on the Home Run Derby tomorrow. Let’s go… NATIONAL LEAGUE!
Now we switch gears to the Home Run Derby, which happens TONIGHT at 8 PM. 

Tonight is shaping up to be a great contest with some big names in the contest along with some up and coming stars. The National League has a definite advantage sporting 4 of the league’s top slugging first basemen. Ryan Howard (22 HR), Prince Fielder (22 HR), Adrian Gonzalez (24 HR), and Albert Pujols (32 HR) will take the stage to represent the NL tonight. Joe Mauer (15 HR), Nelson Cruz (22 HR), Brandon Inge (21 HR), and Carlos Pena (24 HR) put on for the AL. 

My first-round duds for this contest are Brandon Inge and Joe Mauer. 

I just don’t see those two guys doing well in this competition. Neither of them has ever been known as a big power hitter. Joe Mauer makes his living with singles and gap shots, being of the best average hitters in the game. Brandon Inge has really come out of nowhere this season and I really don’t see him hitting more than 3 homers in the first round. I pick these two, along with Albert Pujols and Adrian Gonzalez to be eliminated in the first round. As much hype there is for Albert in this contest, he has just never struck me as a guy who can put on a show in batting practice. It just seems like he is too good of a hitter to do well in this competition. Let’s just hope it doesn’t throw off his swing and affect his run at the triple crown when the season starts up again. 
My first-round studs are Nelson Cruz and Ryan Howard.

I personally love Nelson Cruz. I think he is going to be the surprise of this contest and put up a big number in the first round. I’ll give him 15 homers. Ryan Howard is quickly becoming a seasoned veteran in this contest, he won it in 2006 at PNC Park and I like his chances again this year. He is the most experienced of the bunch this year and I think he should be the favorite tonight. I would look for 12-16 homers from him in round 1 tonight. So these two, along with Prince Fielder and Adrian Gonzalez advance to the second round. 
From there I forsee Ryan Howard and Prince Fielder advancing to the finals. I think Cruz will be tired out from his surprising first round and won’t fair well in the 2nd round. Adrian Gonzalez will fall short by a couple home runs and it’ll be Fielder vs. Howard. 

I can see this becoming one of the greatest slug-offs in derby history. Both of these guys have unhumanlike power and can pound the ball all over the place. They are young and will have a lot of gas in the tank to put on a show deep into the St. Louis night. My emerging champion is Prince Fielder, by the score of 11-10. In honor of Prince, I am dawning his player t-shirt all day today. At the end of the night, a home run Prince will become a home run King.


I don’t know….I think both teams are equally stacked….The NL tends to be more of a base hit and running team, but the AL has hard throwing pitchers and plenty of power hitters..Who knows, maybe the NL can reverse the losing streak tomorrow… But, I’ll still be rooting for my American League.

Haha, good post, I think the NL will do good, but with Halladay and the bats of the AL, it will be hard for the NL pitching. I have some Cal Ripken Trivia,

Great entry!! Those are great reasons, and I think it’s going to happen. It’s about time!! GO NATIONAL LEAGUE!!

The NL is stacked.

You sound like you know your game, though it is VERY clear you have NEVER seen Albert in BP, folks come out to the park WHERE EVER he goes just to watch his BP>last series in NY against the Mets in June, the Park was packed for BP. Albert sent the ball to the upper deck so many times I cant count. It was a great show. Did you even see him the last time he was in the Home Run Derby ?? He did not make it to the final round, but it was a show..The one thing Albert Likes is COMPETITION !! He wont make it to the final round, but he will put on a show.
As for Pittsburg in a World Series, you have MANY years to wait.
Your way to young to remember when the Pirate’s where there last, wearing those silly uniforms with those boxed striped caps..

gawh man Mike Williams, loved the guy. didnt realize that happened in 96. I remember Giles and Kendall being on the same team in a game one time. 98 maybe, I dont know. We also had Sanchez and Jay Bay in the game in 06. While I cant say im cheering for the Nl, i do hope they win. just want to see a good game.


What!? No love for Carlos!? C’mon, the guy is a born slugger.

I agree that Mauer and Inge won’t figure much into the contest. I also thing (gasp!) that Albert will be bounced early. He is too good a hitter to succeed in a contest that rewards guys who have an upper cut swing and, therefore, strike out alot.

Finals: Cruz and ‘Los.

Winner: Carlos.

Its almost time for the derby! Let’s go Los. C’mon man. I voted Los so hopefully he wins. Please comment :)

Jay Bay started in ’06. I remeber voting liek crazy. everyone in pittsburgh did. PNC Park needed a hometown boy to be starting. He wasnt in the derby then though. just in 2005 in Detroit


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: